Nutritional yeast is a staple in the vegan pantry—it provides a cheesy, nutty flavor that would otherwise be missing without cheese. But what do you do when you don't have any or can't have it due to a yeast intolerance? Here are the best nutritional yeast substitutes.
What is nutritional yeast?
It's a deactivated yeast from a strain of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a single-celled fungus often used in winemaking, baking, and brewing. It's grown in a nutrient-rich medium such as molasses, then washed and dried with heat to deactivate it. Because it's deactivated it cannot leaven, so don't try to use it in baked goods that call for yeast like bread. It's best used for its umami flavor and thickening capabilities.
Nutritional yeast has a nutty, cheesy flavor that's great for making dairy-free cheesy sauces. It can also thicken soups or can act like parmesan cheese by sprinkling it on top of pasta or popcorn.
It has grown in popularity in recent years and frequently shows up in dairy-free or vegan recipes. Most large chain grocery stores now carry it in the baking aisle near the specialty flours but you can also often find it sold in bulk bins at health food stores.
If you aren't familiar with nutritional yeast (also known as nooch), check out everything you need to know about nutritional yeast from what it is, its nutritional benefits, how to use it, and more.
Is nutritional yeast the same as yeast extract?
They may sound like they'd be the same thing but they're not. They are both produced from the same type of yeast but through a different process. Nutritional yeast is a whole-cell inactive yeast while yeast extract is made by breaking down the cell walls of the yeast to release their contents.
This results in a stronger flavor that's great for enhancing other flavors. You'll often see yeast extract added to canned soup, frozen dinners, and salty snacks. It's also the main ingredient in Vegemite and Marmite, the salty spreads from Australia.
Yeast extract can come in many forms including a thick gel or a moist powder. Nutritional yeast is always dry but can range from large flakes to fine powder.
Benefits of nutritional yeast
Nutritional yeast lives up to its name and has many nutritional and health benefits. If fortified, it's a great source of B vitamins including B12, Niacin, Riboflavin, B6, and Folate. This can be beneficial on a vegan diet where B12 can be lacking. It can also come unfortified which still contains a moderate amount of B vitamins, but will not contain B12, so make sure to check the packaging before relying on it as your main source of B12.
Nutritional yeast is also considered a complete protein, containing all nine essential amino acids in the recommended amounts. It also contains around 4 grams of protein in just one tablespoon of nutritional yeast. Additionally, it contains zinc, selenium, manganese and iron and provides powerful antioxidants such as glutathione and selenomethionine.
Best nutritional yeast substitutes
If you're familiar with nutritional yeast then you know it can be hard to replicate the flavor when you don't have it. But fear not, there are actually several ways you can replace nutritional yeast when you've just run out or you can't seem to find it at the store. Bonus: many of these you probably already have on hand!
Nutritional yeast provides both flavor and texture so we'll be walking through how to replicate both of these characteristics in different ways.
First up, flavor. The following are the best substitutes to replicate the cheesy, nutty, umami-like flavor of nutritional yeast.
Soy sauce or liquid aminos
Soy sauce imparts a savory flavor to dishes making it a great replacement for nutritional yeast. Liquid aminos, often sold as coconut aminos, look and taste similar to soy sauce but have a milder flavor. It's also a good soy-free and gluten-free option. Either one will work to replace nutritional yeast.
You may want to adjust the salt in the dish if adding these as they will increase the overall saltiness. Low-sodium soy sauce is a great choice.
To replace nutritional yeast, start with about ½ or ⅓ of what the recipe calls for and increase to taste. Consider also adjusting the liquids in the dish if nutritional yeast is a large portion of the recipe.
Marmite or Vegemite are two popular yeast extract brands. These concentrated pastes have a stronger yet similar flavor to nutritional yeast which makes them an excellent alternative.
Use 2 teaspoons for every one tablespoon of nutritional yeast.
White miso paste
Miso paste is a savory, salty paste made from fermented soybeans. It's a great substitute for making creamy sauces like a dairy-free cheesy sauce.
Same as with soy sauce, use about ⅓ of what the recipe calls for when replacing nutritional yeast with miso paste.
Another great substitute is ground cashews. Grind them into a powder and sprinkle on pasta like you would parmesan. Or soak them and blend them into a vegan cheese sauce. In fact, many vegan cheese sauces use cashews as well so you wouldn't need to add another ingredient.
If using raw cashews, add a little salt to impart a similar savory flavor as nutritional yeast. Otherwise, use salted roasted cashews.
For the cashew powder, use equal parts cashew powder to nutritional yeast.
A good nut-free option is shelled sunflower seeds. You can soak them and use them in the same way as soaked cashews. You can also grind them into a powder to sprinkle on pasta or popcorn. Adjust salt if using salted sunflower seeds.
We love this vegetable bouillon paste that provides a really rich, savory flavor. This is a great substitute for nutritional yeast in cheese sauces and soups. It is very salty so keep that in mind when replacing nutritional yeast with it. Vegetable bouillon cubes also work well.
If you're in a pinch and don't have vegetable bouillon you can use vegetable broth. The concentration of flavor is less, but it will still add that savory, umami flavor that the dish would be missing otherwise. Keep in mind that as a liquid, vegetable broth will change the consistency of the dish. This is best used in curries, soups and stews that already require a lot of liquid.
Dried porcini mushrooms
Dried and chopped mushrooms can help to replicate the flavor of nutritional yeast but porcini does it best. Porcini mushrooms have a deeper nutty and earthy flavor than most other mushrooms, making them the best replacement but any mushroom will do.
Dried mushrooms are best used in a soup or stir fry rather than a cheesy sauce since it won't be able to impart the same cheesy, salty taste that nutritional yeast would.
Nutritional yeast provides a thickening effect when added to sauces, soups, and stews. Here are the best recommendations to replicate the texture and thickening.
Brewer's yeast is most commonly used for making beer and bread and comes in the form of powder or flakes similar to nutritional yeast. It is more bitter than nutritional yeast but it does provide a similar thickening effect. This is best used in cheese sauces or soups. Don't worry, your soup won't rise, but it will be thicker than other alternatives.
Use ½ - ⅓ of what the recipe calls for at first and adjust from there depending on taste and thickness preferred.
You can use chickpea flour to thicken soups and stews just as you would nutritional yeast. In small portions such as a tablespoon, it's a one-to-one replacement, making it easy and convenient. If your recipe calls for a considerable amount of nutritional yeast such as a cup, use ⅔ cup of chickpea flour. Best of all, you can make your own chickpea flour in a pinch if you have dried chickpeas in your pantry.
You can also use your homemade chickpea flour to sprinkle on top of pasta or popcorn, just make sure to toast the flour in the oven first. Spread the flour out on a baking try and bake at 300F for a few minutes. This also helps bring out the nutty flavor.
Onion flakes are another good substitute for texture. The flaky consistency is similar to nutritional yeast flakes which is great for adding to dishes where you don't want to affect the liquids too much. Just keep in mind that in large amounts the final dish will have a stronger onion flavor.
There you have it—lots of great ways to replace nutritional yeast if you've run out or have an intolerance to yeast.
Although these substitutions are not identical to nutritional yeast, they still make excellent replacements in a pinch. To achieve the best results it can help to mix and match the texture and flavor replacements depending on the dish. This will allow you to customize the perfect substitute for your needs!
There's a good chance you have several of these on hand so check out the recipe card below for the best combinations to recreate the texture and flavor.
More easy cooking substitutions
- The best substitutes to replace eggs in baking and cooking.
- Coconut sugar substitutes and an easy homemade replacement
- 8 easy honey substitutes
- Substitutes for coconut vinegar including a diy alternative (that also makes a great gift!)
- Easy vegan protein substitutes for any meal
Homemade Nutritional Yeast Substitute
Choose a Base:
- chickpea flour, * see notes below
- dried mushrooms
- brewer's yeast
- ground roasted cashews
- ground roasted sunflower seeds
- 1 teaspoon salt, reduce when using pre-salted cashews and sunflower seeds or brewer's yeast
- 1 teaspoon onion flakes
- 1 teaspoon garlic powder
- ¼ teaspoon turmeric powder
- 1 teaspoon vegetable bouillon powder, optional, reduce salt if using
- Choose your base (or several) and add 1 cup to a small mixing bowl. If using several, make sure the total adds up to 1 cup, such as ½ cup chickpea flour and ½ cup ground cashews.
- Add the seasonings and mix well. Use as you would nutritional yeast in recipes for a similar nutty, cheesy flavor and texture!
- Store in an airtight container in a cool, dry place for up to 6 months.
This article was originally published April 19, 2021 and has been updated with additional substitutes, tips, and homemade recipe on March 23, 2023.
Thank you for this comprehensive article! I tried the nutritional yeast substitute with roasted ground cashews and the seasonings (minus salt) plus a little brewer's yeast and it was perfect! Definitely the best replacement I've tried so far. Thank you!
My receipe calls for chick pea flour & red lentil flour.. but it also calls for 2 tsp of nutritional yeast. Can I use 2 more tsp of chick pea flour?.
Yes that would work! It will have a little different flavor without the nutritional yeast but it should result in a similar consistency.
Does the porcini mushrooms have to be soaked like the sunflower seeds and then blended with the cashews?
You can blend them into a powder to be similar consistency to nutritional yeast. If you want to blend with cashews you could do dry or soak first, just depends on what you're making. If you want a "cheesy" topping like parmesan I would blend both dry, but if making a sauce or adding to something like curry/stew you could soak first to make it smoother. Hope that helps!
I've looking for alternatives for a while now! Thank you for the very helpful article
You're so welcome! Glad it was helpful 🙂
It is very helpful! Thanks'
So glad you found it helpful! 🙂
I was looking for a nutritional substitute, not a flavour substitute, but outside blackstrap molasses I doubt that there is one.
I cannot have nutritional or brewer's yeast, because I can't tolerate the MSG in it, which is a product of its creation. Glutamates.
(I had had the un-debittered brewer's yeast in the 70s, and found it really good for me, energy and nutrition. But, perhaps now that brewer's yeast is debittered? and that stuff in the 70s was VERY funky tasting), now I can't handle it.)
I tried again with nutritional yeast this time, because I had started drinking hi-test coffee again after two years off it. It was a bit of a whim, and after a couple of weeks, it resulted in my being unable to sleep, and getting some fairly fiery neuropathy in my feet and ankles. So I stopped that silliness of course, sold the coffee maker, and to replenish my B vitamins I decided to take nutritional yeast within about 2 weeks of quitting the latest bout of coffee. Made in a Dutch coffee maker priced at over $400CAD just for reference, very good coffee, but very potent.
After a week and a half taking a tablespoon of the yeast daily, I had a sudden attack of heart palpitations, and a thumping heart, that did not subside for two days. THEN my daughter dug around into scientific reports, read up on it, and how bad MSG is for you. So that's that. It could have linked back to the coffee, but I had been off that for 3 weeks or so. I've never been able to tolerate MSG, just didn't realize that it's in brewer's, torula, and nutritional yeast.
I am wondering if the glutamates/MSG are a side effect of the process of debittering, maybe that's the problem. I did not mind the funky taste of the original brewer's yeast at all, and wish the original was still available.
Another thing that has changed is blackstrap molasses, also a source of B vitamins and iron. We used to put a spoonful of that in hot water and drink it, and it was foul tasting. Now "blackstrap" tastes about the same as regular molasses, and I wonder if it is as effective.. I'm going to try some unsulphured organic blackstrap, and see how that goes.
Meanwhile, people, especially Americans, need to stop being such cowards about things that are not sweet, or overly salted. The food giants will overcompensate.
I also have an MSG problem. Besides watching out for MSG in foods, there are foods high in "manufactured free glutamates" that are also a problem for me. You might want to watch out for those if you react to MSG.